|
Frequently
Asked Questions
What
are the types of graffiti? How
is one type distinguished from others? Gang graffiti tends to be territorial (i.e., confined to "the Hood"), while Hip-Hop graffiti is regional; Gangs use graffiti to mark territory, intimidate, or recruit, and they incorporate gang symbols (stars, pitchforks, etc) in their graffiti. Hip-hop taggers use graffiti to achieve what the subculture calls "fame"; they operate in "crews" (3-5 person teams), which usually have a unique, 3-digit name (e.g., "ATS", standing for the "As They Sleep" Crew; "CMW" standing for the "Chicago's Most Wanted" Crew); each member of the crew usually has a unique graffiti moniker (e.g., "KORL" or "WERK" or "JEDI"). Thus, a vandalism site is typically marked with one or more monikers plus the crew name (initials). Within the subculture, there is a hierarchy of graffiti: (1) simple tags, in a single color; (2) throw-ups (bubble-type graffiti, with at least two colors); and (3) pieces (or masterpieces, the most complex). In general, the higher up the hierarchy a tagger goes, the more fame. Also, for pieces, the quality of the "art" comes to play. Additional "fame" points are accrued for applying graffiti to a high place (top of a building or a billboard); these are called "heavens" tags. Hip-hop taggers have been known to use grappling hooks or steal bucket trucks to achieve a "heavens" tag. Gang graffiti is incidental to other activities (violence, drugs), and the application of graffiti is often an entry-level assignment. For Hip-hop taggers, graffiti is the main focus of the individuals, and it often becomes addictive behavior. Gang graffiti is locally organized. While Hip-hop might also be local, the vandals network through pro-graffiti magazines and on the Internet. (e.g., there have been instances of German vandals, communicating on the Internet with NYC counterparts, eventually resulting in the Germans flying to NYC, participating in several "bombing runs" (large-scale application of graffiti to an area) there, then the NYC counterparts returning to Germany with their friends for more of the same there.) There are over 1,000 hip-hop graffiti sites on the Internet! Gang graffiti is often not prominent (e.g., on a garage door in "the Hood"). Hip-hop graffiti is, by design, prominent and very visible. The vandals cannot achieve "fame" if their "art" is not seen. Thus, it is applied to billboards, traffic light control boxes, freeway signs, downtown buildings….places where many will see it. By some estimates, gang graffiti only accounts for 10% of the national graffiti problem, whereas hip-hop accounts for 90%. It is estimated that US municipalities spend approximately $15 billion per year to respond to graffiti vandalism. For law enforcement, many avenues, not feasible or practical for gang vandals, are open with hip-hop vandals, including license plates, special surveillance equipment, search warrants, conspiracy law, and expert testimony. Don't
"free walls" provide an effective alternative for youth
creativity, thus reducing graffiti vandalism? The "free wall" solution ignores hip-hop subculture mores and tagger motivation. Taggers do graffiti vandalism in order to win "fame" within the subculture. In general, the greater the number of tags, the greater the "fame" for a given vandal. Thus, if a community establishes a "free wall", graffiti vandals will probably place their moniker there. But they will also put the same monikers, as graffiti, throughout the community, because this gives them "fame". The NoGraf Network has actively sought to identify communities where "free walls" have worked. We have found none. Their failure is manifested in two ways: (1) as mentioned above, in general, the same youth who tag at the free wall continue to place the same tags, as vandalism, throughout the community. (2) There is usually a "spillover" effect around the "free wall", resulting in all adjacent property being tagged, including buildings, benches, trees, pavement, and even grass. Following are comments from several US and Australian communities on their "free wall" experiments and the results: City of Palo Alto We do not have a free wall. What we do have is a skateboard bowl, in which we allow graffiti inside the bowl. Actually we just don't remove it there. To my knowledge there has never been any advertising of allowance of graffiti inside the skate bowl. This bowl is in one of our parks; as expected, this park continually has the most graffiti and the most frequency of graffiti in the city. Thus, the "oozing effect"!!!!!!! In the bowl we will get some very artistic graffiti, full of colors, mural-like. So we get some taggers who drive to our bowl to do some of their artwork. Then of course we get all the small tags and scribbles as well as bottles and cans. If you talk the employee who has to clean up in and around the bowl, he would tell you that we should just close the bowl, period. Also some skate boarders don't like the paint on the bowl, saying it makes it slippery. During the two years I've been here I have seen the constant spread of the graffiti from the bowl to the fence around the bowl, benches, bike path, phone and every where they can in the vicinity of the skate bowl. Of course we don't post any signs about graffiti only in the skate bowl, so some may assume it is also allowed to tag the path in front of the bowl. I think the bottom line of the free wall is dependent on location of wall and "taggable" areas around the wall. In other words a free wall in the middle of a large lawn behind the police station just might work.
Huntington Beach, California. Nice
idea but then the taggers coming to see
the wall tagged the neighborhoods around the wall and also the kids
just started tagging the wall
without permits that were required.
They tried using sea
walls at the beach for ‘approved graffiti zones’, but they soon
had businesses and residents
complaining because of the near-area vandalism
the zones brought. Eventually
the program was scrapped.” Venice Beach,
California. (The pit).
This is the most well known…the
area was buffed clean, then a contest was organized and the
entire area done with beautiful
murals…. later, the vandals came and they have tagged over the
murals and destroyed the area.
What started as a nice project turned the
area into a slum. San Fernando Valley,
California. Levitz
Furniture Store. The
sanctioned wall not only caused
damage to other walls and trees on the same property,
but to every building or structure within a mile of the wall. It was a magnet for every
untalented writer. San Francisco, California. “Psycho City" or "Cycle City" was probably the largest free wall in the northern hemisphere…Graffiti vandals came from all over the world just to tag and to take pictures of themselves with their tag in Psycho City. All of the streets leading into and out of Psycho City were covered with tags from vandals drawn to the West Coast’s Mecca of graffiti. It started with one wall on Plumbers’ Union Hall and spread to an area that covered over two square blocks from top to bottom…this was on Market Street…only 5 blocks from City Hall. The neighborhood had given up on it and, although vandals were arrested, the cases would be dropped by the District Attorney, because it wasn’t clear that you couldn’t tag there. It seemed hopeless that the mixed residential/commercial area could ever be restored. The whole area for blocks around suffered from the constant tagging. This was proof enough that legal walls won’t work. On August 27, 1995 our graffiti team restored the walls by removing all the graffiti in Psycho City. Operating a stealth mission and over one weekend, using hundreds of gallons of paint, armies of workers, high rangers and PERMISSION to remove the graffiti…On Monday, all the graffiti was gone. Each morning, before dawns early light, we would check for retagging. The first week we returned every day, but it only took a few minutes to remove any tags, and they never got to take a picture of the tags. Soon, the retagging tapered off to once a week, and now, it goes for months without any tags. The graffiti vandals put the word out on the Internet that Psycho City was dead, and that was the end of a west coast graffiti icon…What does this prove? Free walls do NOT work, and, with persistence, any area, no matter how bad, can be turned around. We know. We did it! Rockford, Illinois.
The Aldeen Dam, located in a Rockford Park, was
previously a place where high school students, with a permit,
could spend all night
decorating the walls with boasts about their schools.
In July, 1997, with the
arrival of hip-hop taggers in Rockford, the Aldeen Dam became entirely
dominated by hip-hop taggers only.
Almost all graffiti at Aldeen is done by the
same taggers and crews that vandalize the residences,
businesses, billboards,
railroad cars, and signage of Rockford.
Further, the number of tags
at Aldeen is proportionate to a crew or tagger’s frequency of
vandalism on the streets of
Rockford. This fact alone
would seem to disprove the claim that
a “free wall” might be an effective tool to combat graffiti. Aldeen also displays
the “spread-to-all-adjacent-areas” characteristic which other free
walls manifest: At
Aldeen, in the areas adjacent to the free wall, there is
graffiti on light poles, the grass, trees, the parking lot,
trash containers, park benches,
and walking trails through the woods. San Jose,
California. There were
several unsuccessful attempts to provide free walls where vandals
could legally write on walls. The result in each case was the increase
of graffiti in the surrounding community, as the vandals (they are not
artists) were unable to fight the urge to tag anything and everything
on the way to and from the free walls. Furthermore, the content
matter depicted in the free walls was sometimes inappropriate and the
City was forced to remove the graffiti at the taxpayer¹s cost. Additionally,
vandals used the sidewalk in front of the free wall to test paint
colors and would drip latex paint on the sidewalk when they were
repainting the wall for a clean canvas, again requiring the City to
spend tax dollars to clean the sidewalk. Law Enforcement Tagger Specialist. The following comments were received from a very involved Law Enforcement officer specializing in tagger suppression......... "When I was a part of
the team in the Long Beach undercover sting operation,
I suggested an area of free walls back in 1991.
None of the taggers were interested.
The reasons why they were not interested:
Free walls will always attract the taggers that will not respect the concept and you have a Huntington Beach situation all over again. The only reason why there is a persistence to make this "free wall" mistake again is someone's ego is getting in the way of common sense. If a person goes to the Venice "pit" where it is similar to a free wall, all you have to do is look around the neighborhood and its got graffiti on it. The taggers did not limit it to the pit. I hope the folly of free walls begins to sink in, those people that say it is a success often times hide the disaster it causes. I would like to visit a city the size of LA and see where a free wall concept is working. What's really working and not working may boil down to 'from whose perspective?'. G’day from Perth, Western Australia I do understand why people feel that giving graffitists’ space to do graffiti legally is a great idea. I used to supervise and regularly repainted a “free wall” in Perth’s suburb of Burswood. The logic is: if they can do it legally, they won’t have to do it illegally, so the vandalism will stop. I have to admit that I use to feel exactly the same way. What I found out was that it was one of those unfortunate, well meant ideas, which work exactly the opposite way to its original intent. In my experience, the first drawback was that the “free wall” attracted graffitists from other, often distant areas. Then, after the initial honeymoon period, illegal graffiti started to increase on surrounding properties. (I have pictures of cleaning the area with Ian Matthews to prove it :O) It got so bad that a local business owner called my boss and threatened to take legal action against the organization I was working for at that time. One day I found a sign on our “free wall” which highlighted yet another, often forgotten aspect of the “legal wall” debate. The sign stated: “My mum thinks I’m in school, fuk school, this is my school” (look at the small photo attached). Based on my experience I believe that it is much easier to stop the “free wall” from happening, than to try to close it. The instigators often don’t want to lose face and may have difficult time admitting that they were wrong. It is worth to point out that often those ideas get started on recommendation of a youth worker or a local youth council, who may care deeply about young people and truly believe in the merit of the idea. Well, as I mentioned before I did so myself. Now, I have to admit that it was just ignorance. I took my Burswood experience and had two battles (one short one very long) with two local authorities to close legal walls. At this stage I accept that it is just a fact of life that well meaning people will come up with this “natural and logical” solution. As you would have read in the recent article from Perth, our state government which disbanded a very successful graffiti program wants now put more legal walls. I don’t have any sympathy for vandals, but I have great empathy for young people in general. I feel that adults often come up with “brilliant solutions” and young people end up paying the price. I go along with Jim’s suggestions about taking responsibility for the consequences of installing a “free wall”. Municipality or corporate body wanting to put a “free wall” should be ready to “sign a contract” with the community that they will take full responsibility for any adverse effects arising from the presence of the wall. Before creating a “free wall” they also should come up with a plan, let’s call it a “wall plan”, which would provide answers to following questions (and more): Is anyone going to monitor the “free wall”? Is the wall going to be repainted regularly to provide fresh “canvas” and avoid conflicts arising from graffitist painting over each other “pieces”? What happens if someone will write obscenity on the “free wall”? What action will be taken if there was: “F… the transit” or “Kill Police” written on the “free wall”? Is it going to stay there or will it be removed? What if the same tag or color piece as on the “free wall” appears on surrounding properties? Is the “original” on the “free wall”? Will it be allowed to stay there? Is it going to be removed? Who will make a decision on what’s acceptable? Who is going to remove it? Who is going to pay for the removal? Is it going to be removed while young people are present at the wall? Who will guarantee personal safety of the person removing graffiti form the “free wall”? Will the authority proposing “legal wall” provide conflict resolution training to people removing graffiti from the wall, since they most likely will be confronted and asked to explain their action to young people present at the wall. Will the graffitist whose tag constantly show on the “free wall” and at the same time on surrounding properties will be allowed to continue to do so without any consequences? If yes, will the authority make restitution to compensate property owners? If not, will the vandal be ban from the “free wall”? Who will enforce that ban? What consequences will be in place for non-compliance by the vandal? How it will be enforced? What consequences will be in place for the authority for non-enforcement? Are there any possession laws in force? What will Police do if they stop at 2am a young person with a backpack full of cans who says that he was making his way to the legal wall? What about health and safety issues? Will young people use face masks? Who will enforce it? Who will supply mask? Would the authority carry liability insurance? Would those using the facility provided by the authority (“legal wall”) be allow to take legal action against the authority for negligence in case of health problems resulting from prolonged exposure to toxins in paint. Could such legal action be taken let’s say 10 years later? Would the authority inform taxpayers that there is such possibility, before creating the “free wall”? If such legal action takes place who will tax payers have to cover the bill? Will those wanting to paint on the “legal wall” be asked to sign a waiver? How would such waivers be distributed, collected and verified? Would parent have to sign waivers for minors? Etc, etc, etc… I’m sure that if we put our heads together we could create several pages of similar questions. I thing especially those dealing with negligence, liability, and litigation may have the authority contemplating the idea of a “free wall” pause for a moment to remember that "road to hell is paved with good intentions". Bondi Beach, Sydney, Australia: Waverly Council in Sydney approved a "free wall" in Bondi Beach, arguably one of the worlds most famous beaches. Within 6 months Bondi Beach became one of the worst affected areas in Sydney. They now spend $3000 per month keeping a 1 kilometre strip of beach and retail shops free of graffiti. Why
should parents be concerned that their children are involved in graffiti?
Isn't it merely a passing youthful transgression? (1) danger; (2) a potential criminal record, (3) anti-social values, (4) financial loss (5) addiction. (1) Danger.
Graffiti vandals usually do their work under cover of darkness,
particularly between the hours of 10:00 PM and 3:00 AM.
Further, their vandalism
is usually done in isolated areas, like railroad yards.
But in addition to the
danger of being in isolated areas during the hours of darkness, there
is inherent danger in climbing
to the graffiti target. Hip-hop
vandals place an added premium
on what they call a "heavens" tag, graffiti placed on a
difficult target, like a
high billboard, a freeway sign, or the top of a building. Many vandals have suffered
serious injury or death while they were in the process of attempting a
"heavens" tag. Also,
some, when climbing to their target, have been mistaken for
burglars and shot. (2) Criminal Records. Criminal records are possible from two general standpoints. First, within the hip-hop subculture, vandals are encouraged to "rack" (steal) the paint they use. This is sometimes accomplished by shoplifting and sometimes by setting their paint aside in an area which can be accessed after store closing hours (e.g., the home and garden section, which is secured by a chain-link fence), then returning later, and breaking into the store with a bolt cutter to pick up their paint. Second, and more obvious, is the criminal record which can result from their vandalism. With hip-hop graffiti vandalism, such offenses are often out of the misdemeanor range and well into the felony range. The following are some approximate costs to abate what are frequent targets of graffiti vandalism:
A graffiti vandal recently prosecuted in California was fined $100,000 and, due to parole violation, was sentenced to 36 months in prison; another, a high school senior in Milwaukee, was sentenced to 51 months in prison. (3) Anti-social Values.
The YMCA, a family-oriented American institution,
identifies four character-development values: respect, honesty,
caring, and responsibility.
Would you agree that those are desirable for your children?
Would you also agree that your children's values are either
strengthened or weakened by
those with whom they associate? Would
you like to see who they associate
with when they choose graffiti? Take
a cyber-trip to one of their most popular
newsgroup discussion forums, "alt.graffiti".
Once you have been there, draw
your own conclusions about the character-development potential of such
associates. You can go
there directly by clicking here: Deja.com
then, at the site, (1) click on "search discussions", (2)
then enter "graffiti" as a subject, (3) and, finally, turn
"on" the checkmark in the "alt.graffiti" box.
(4) Financial Loss.
Financial loss may result from (1) attorney fees and (2)
retribution. When a juvenile is arrested for graffiti vandalism, parents
can expect to spend
thousands of dollars in attorney fees before the case reaches final
disposition. In
addition, depending on parental responsibility laws in your
jurisdiction, you may be ordered by the court to make
restitution for your child's vandalism.
The amount would depend upon the law in your jurisdiction, the
judge's decision, and the amount of vandalism done by your
child. In a recent
case in California, a tagger was convicted, as an adult, on
several counts of vandalism,
and he was fined $100,000. At
the time of his conviction, his parents
were still paying back $42,000 in court-ordered restitution for
similar offenses, committed
when he was a juvenile. (5) Addiction. Although no clinical studies have been conducted, it is becoming evident that graffiti vandalism can be addictive, and that the conduct continues well beyond teenage years. For example, a professional engineer, dressed in white shirt and tie, driving a brand new BMW, was recently arrested for a series of graffiti vandalism incidents in a large metropolitan area; he subsequently served 9 months in jail for his offenses. In another instance, the girlfriend of a Los Angeles tagger stated that he had previously been addicted to cocaine, but, since he got into graffiti, he dropped the cocaine addiction and was addicted to graffiti. And still another: the following is an actual Internet posting by a 24-year-old vandal. Read on! "Sometimes I'll just sit and wonder why I love to bomb. How is it that I am addicted to this? I never thought I'd still be doing it almost halfway through my 20's with no intentions of stopping soon or at all really.. I have no spare time now with work and shit but all the extra time I have is spent painting or sketching or catching freights.. calling in sick because I want to go out and bomb that night or being really tired because I had to wake up early so I could get flicks of what I did the night before. I cant stop. Its fucked up. haha. Yeah. I'm sure someone will have some witty little retort so whatever.. If you're truly down you know it.. fuck everything and everyone else. Peace. And the response to that, from a fellow graffiti vandal: "Damn! My thoughts exactly!!!!!" Finally, a note from a tagger attending an expensive private prep school: " i get reall low on self esteem...like real low..i think about what would i do with out graff.and i have nothing...i am running up a dark highway right now where the cars do not have head lights...my life is getting dangerous..i got involved with some gangs and almost got killed and i just got real low from people discouraging me..i almost couldn't take it..it was horrible....i was at a crossroad and some streets were one way and i picked one..my life is going down the toilet bowl like a dead roach.. iwalked down this road and now there ain't away back...i feel like i tottally fucked up my life recently and i don't exactly know how and when..so i can;t fix it...like right now i can;t even think about why it is so bad nor do i want to cuz i will get real low again.....my reputation right now is shit.....stay tru too u too...yo and as far as we are concerned i was very impressed with your knowledge of how a writer thinks...because it was mostly true....you know more then most....and you deserve much props.....peace" . A subsequent note from the
same graffiti vandal indicated that he was contemplating suicide. Had
his parents been informed and vigilant, and had they
intervened soon enough, his life might have taken a different
course! What
are the sentiments of graffiti victims? Toronto, Canada Malmo, Sweden Rockford, Illinois (When told that many hip-hop
taggers consider their vandalism to be art….) Phoenix, Arizona Phoenix, Arizona Phoenix, Arizona "A large part of the negative reaction to graffiti is the lack of respect that is shown when "my" property is defaced (public property is "mine", too). If I had wanted you to scrawl on my wall, I would have asked you to do it. If you had asked me for permission, I might have considered it but you didn't give me that opportunity. By your clandestine actions, you have taken away my right to determine the disposition of my property and you have said to me that what I want doesn't matter, only what you want. You are creating stereotypes yourself, when you generically refer to graffiti as "art" and taggers as "artists". To be "art", a piece should have some sort of appeal; either aesthetic or emotional. Wall scrawl that is done by "writers" has neither. I have seen photos of pieces that are truly artistic and deserve to be viewed but, when taken as part of the whole body of graffiti, there are damn few of them." Phoenix, Arizona Milwaukee, Wisconsin Adelaide, South
Australia Perth, Western Australia Washington, D.C. Missouri
University
A month prior to graduation, graffiti has been applied to the porous stone
columns facing Francis Quadrangle; the columns have always played an
important role in commencement ceremonies. "I
just think it's terrible; the columns are a huge tradition.
Anyone that would do something like that obviously does not
understand the meaning behind it." Savannah,
Georgia.
Having moved
to Savannah two years ago, he noted a very small amount of unsightly
graffiti while his realtor showed him about town. He was pleased with the upkeep and apparent commitment to
keeping the city clean from "spray paint litter".
"That…is a startling contrast
to the scene today. I took a
walk around just one square recently and counted 27 separate pieces of
spray-paint blight on building walls, windows, utility boxes and newspaper
stands….I challenge citizens to join me in doing something about this
increasing problem….it robs us of money, time, and probably most
importantly, the value of beauty in our lives." Lake
Tahoe, Nevada.
Customers at the Head to Toe Salon are furious over the increase in
graffiti after the Memorial Day weekend.
Call it a sign of youthful boasting or an example of misspent
energy, the graffiti has become an intrusive reality of big city life
invading their rural town. Graffiti seems more outrageous in an area
cherished for visual beauty. "Taggers - as the morons with
spray paint cans call themselves - indeed seem to have been busy Memorial
Day weekend. The remains of their juvenile antics can be seen on shops,
fences, government buildings and just about any other surface that can be
reached without too much effort….It's disgusting.
It reminds me of dogs marking their territory." San Francisco, California. A year ago
he had noted the increase in graffiti vandalism in San Francisco,
expressing concern that graffiti had made Rome ugly, and the same fate
might be in store for San Francisco. "…the epidemic of
graffiti vandalism has exploded. Look
around. Our buildings, walls, alleyways, signs, lampposts, parking
meters, mailboxes, streetcars, buses, bus shelters -- everything is a
target. Have you seen
Chinatown lately? There has
been a steady change in the look and feel of our city….Visualize how the
city will look after another year or two of this…" London, England: "I live in Raynes Park - a modest quiet suburb,
but where graffiti vandalism is a massive problem. It's talked about as a
victimless crime but that's nonsense. Every public building, virtually
every shop and many residents have been victimised. Why are these
criminals known as artists? Does that make the numbskull who snaps off a
car aerial a sculptor? But tagging is on a completely different scale,
with a devastating impact."
London, England: "Graffiti is not an artistic expression, it is
merely an expression of contempt for the rest of society. Like all forms
of vandalism it is the offence to others that gives its kick. I suppose
while we are prepared to turn a blind eye we get the environment we
deserve. I am already seeing vans driving around covered in graffiti. It
cannot be long before our cars and front doors are targets. How far does
it have to go before we wake up?"
London, England: "As a surveyor responsible for maintenance on
several housing estates in north-west London, I see a lot of graffiti and
have to remove it too. I've seen the effects on adults who have lived on
the estates for some time and want to improve things. It leaves them
gutted, with a feeling of helplessness especially when the police know the
offenders and their tags. I can take people to areas which were completely
redecorated only weeks ago and now look as if they have never been
touched. The children do it because they can, there is no one to tell them
"no, that's wrong"."
What
is "hip-hop"? How
does graffiti fit in? What
elements should be contained in an effective municipal graffiti program? In general, three
elements should be included in an effective municipal graffiti
program:
Abatement. Speed
should be the paramount goal, but not at the expense of restoring the
property to its pre-vandalism condition. Studies have shown that
the faster graffiti is removed, the less likely is it to return to the
same site. Enforcement.
This includes all actions by police, prosecution, and judicial
elements. Education.
There are three target audiences: (1) community-at-large, (2)
parents, and (3) youth,
particularly in the age-group preceding the normal starting age for
graffiti vandalism. What
Can You Tell Me About NoGraf Members? The
NoGraf Network does not divulge specific personal information about its members.
However, we are happy to share the following overview information:
The Network has members on 6 continents and in 19 countries.
Membership categories include Law Enforcement, Abatement, Vendors,
Community-Based Organizations, Professional Associations, Education, and
Prosecution. In addition to those in countries outside of the United
States, members reside in Washington D.C. and over 100 other US communities in the following states: Arizona, California,
Colorado, Connecticut, Florida, Georgia, Idaho, Illinois, Iowa, Kansas,
Kentucky, Maine, Maryland, Michigan, Minnesota,
Montana, Nevada, New Jersey, New Hampshire, New Mexico, New York, North Dakota, Ohio, Oregon, Pennsylvania, South
Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Utah, Vermont, Virginia, West Virginia, Washington,
and Wisconsin.
|
For more information, or to add
your story here
E-Mail Ranbud@xxxx.starband.net (Remove the xxxx) I will contact you
for more information